Automotive Accessories

Bring a Trailer President Calls the Comment Section the Site's 'Secret Sauce'

Haruki NakamuraOctober 29, 20265 min read15 views

At a glance

  • Howard Swig tells The Drivecast how a WordPress listings blog became a community-run vetting floor, and why that public scrutiny shapes seller results.
  • Bring a Trailer president Howard Swig said on The Drivecast that the auction site's comment section is both its community engine and a self-policing check on the cars it lists. He also acknowledged that the public scrutiny does not suit every seller, and that outcomes tend to track how well a car is prepared before the auction opens.
Silhouetted enthusiasts with flashlights and clipboards inspect a generic classic sedan under garage lights while one examines an identification plate.

Howard Swig, president of Bring a Trailer, credits the auction site's comment section with turning a simple listings blog into a community — and with policing the cars that pass through it. Speaking on The Drivecast, Swig told The Drive that the comment section has become "the secret sauce of what makes it fun and the community component," and that it also serves as a self-policing force.

Swig traced the site back to 2007, when it operated as a WordPress blog and online newsletter during what he described as the golden era of eBay and Craigslist. The founder, he said, was — and still is — hooked on hunting down interesting cars buried on classified sites and marque-specific forums, and that enthusiast following built almost immediately.

A public ledger, and a public vetting

The vetting is concrete rather than abstract. When a 1991 BMW E34 M5 was listed on the site about a decade ago, early in its auction era, commenters moved in quickly: one prolific member of the E34 M5 community ran the VIN and posted the car's full build configuration in the thread. Buyers and sellers get that due diligence for free, and Swig described the dynamic as almost a sport.

Not every seller wants a crowd watching. Swig acknowledged a "subset of individuals who want privacy, want maximum discretion," and noted that Bring a Trailer is a very public forum. The format rewards cars that need explaining: a new 911 Turbo, he said, is close to a commodity whose options can be covered in a few lines, whereas an 80-year-old car that has been crashed and restored three times and mixes original and new parts is exactly where the site can shine. Buyers, he added, like to read a week of comments before bidding on something old and storied. He repeated a line he says often: people want a car with great history but no stories — and you cannot always have both.

For sellers uneasy about a public record of opinions, his answer is preparation. Posting a car with poor photos and unresolved issues leaves the seller chasing problems while bidding is live, and the final number usually reflects the effort made beforehand, he said. Buying a car is fun, Swig noted, while selling is hard work; presenting the car properly, with supporting documentation of the work done, makes for a far better experience.

Moderation as umpiring

Comment moderation remains its own controversy. Swig called commenters potentially "amazing first responders to major issues," and said the site still relies on a self-policing system built in its early days: profane or clearly disallowed comments can be removed, and community members can flag comments as not constructive. Some users are upset when flagged comments vanish, he said, though that outcome often reflects other members clicking the button rather than a moderator's call. He compared the job to an umpire calling balls and strikes — fairness and consistent values get it right most of the time, but decisions rarely satisfy everyone, particularly when a buyer, seller, previous owner and commenter each hold a defensible position.

The remarks land as Bring a Trailer faces competition from outlets such as Cars & Bids, and as its threads have become a spectator sport of their own — the sort of place where a 1992 Volkswagen GTI changing hands for $87,000 draws a crowd and no shortage of hot takes.

Reported by Haruki Nakamura, In-Car Infotainment and Audio Analyst.