Beauty

CTPA panel says beauty misinformation fight needs context, consistency and listening

Naomi SekiguchiOctober 27, 20265 min read8 views

At a glance

  • Scientists, regulators and communicators at the CTPA's first scientific conference debated how to make beauty science clearer without oversimplifying it.
  • At the CTPA's inaugural scientific conference, panelists said context, consistent messaging and meeting consumers where they are can help counter beauty misinformation. They also stressed clearer explanation of peer review, plain language and honesty about scientific uncertainty.
Unbranded cosmetic bottles and lab glassware sit on a pale bench as translucent speech ribbons converge through a magnifying glass.

Beauty's fight against misinformation will depend less on repeating facts and more on putting science into context, speaking consistently and listening to where doubts arise, according to speakers at the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association's first scientific conference.

The members-only event, held at Central Hall Westminster in London, brought government and industry representatives together to discuss public, media and consumer engagement. Panelists examined how scientific evidence, regulatory decision-making and public understanding can converge at a time of information overload.

Context makes risk tangible

Caroline Rainsford, director of science at the CTPA, said in her opening remarks that strong science communication is essential because people in many roles spend their days translating complex information for audiences. In a later panel on building trust, she said context is particularly useful. She recalled explaining to salon professionals that an ingredient banned in nail polish would require wearing two kilograms of polish to approach the level that causes harm. “I think putting things into context really speaks to people,” she said.

Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, agreed and offered an Olympic swimming pool analogy for communicating low concentrations. One pool would take an individual about 4,500 years to drink at two litres a day, he said. Once that is explained, people understand that a drop in a swimming pool is not a lot. “To fight against misinformation, we first have to try and explain and give consumers the key on how to measure or how to understand,” he said.

One voice, but not a monolith

Pissavini also argued that credibility in science requires consistency. He said the industry needs to speak with one voice, and that if dermatologists, doctors and companies stopped saying “I” and started saying “we,” the collective message could be stronger. Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK government's Office for Product Safety and Standards, found the one-voice idea interesting but noted that scientists are not very good at it. Credible science depends on critique and peer review, she said, adding that the profession should be more cognisant of how it communicates with one another.

Pissavini, who is also editor of the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said maintaining peer review is crucial. The challenge is finding reviewers and communicating better with readers inside and outside the industry. Rainsford added that the industry must work collectively to demystify what peer review means, since many people, including industry members, do not understand the process. Transparency about what it involves will be important, she said.

Meet people where they are

Claire Coleman, a journalist, editor and specialist consultant on the science behind beauty, said correcting misinformation should begin where it is found. “You have to meet people where they are and make them understand,” she said, adding that communicators need to stand on the same platform as their audience. Middleton agreed, saying that consumers described by government as hard to reach are often not hard to reach but hard to hear. Taking more responsibility for listening is key, she said.

Coleman also cautioned that the industry cannot convert or reach everyone. Rather than targeting hard-liners, she said, it should focus on “floating voters” – consumers who are uncertain and want to understand better.

Plain language and uncertainty

Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK's Chemical Industries Association, said technical terms and acronyms should be avoided where possible. Messages should be framed from the consumer's perspective and remain precise and clear without losing the science, he said. That becomes tricky with complex subjects such as risk-based exposure, but it should still be the goal. He added that science is not necessarily black and white, and that transparency means acknowledging uncertainties. Companies should be upfront about what is actually unknown rather than avoiding awkward questions.

Emma Meredith, director-general of the CTPA, closed the event by saying that how the industry communicates science, and that it communicates it well, is critical.

Reported by Naomi Sekiguchi, Fragrance and Sensory Analyst.